Total Pageviews

Sunday, June 14, 2015

Why the selfie is more than just narcissism


For any popular “it thing” there is just as much back lash with vocal haters.  So too seems to be seen with the selfie.  More times than not you only hear why the selfie is an epidemic that needs to be done away with.  People who take selfies are labeled as vain, narcissistic, and classless. There seems to be so much judgment and hostility towards a way in which a picture is taken and the people taking those pictures. Like with anything, there are those that take things to more of an extreme, such as those individuals that use a selfie stick; however, I would like to give you the facts for why a selfie is not only appropriate, but healthy.

1.       Opportunity: I am a single mom.  Almost 98% of my day I am completely alone: me and my two toddlers.  Believe it or not, my young children are not very capable at taking a good photo.  I however think I take a decent photo.  What ended up happening that for two years, while I transitioned into singlehood after my divorce and transformed my body, attitude and life I had very few pictures of myself and my transformation.  If there was no way to take a selfie, I wouldn’t have any documentation of this big stage in my life.  Because of the selfie, I have the opportunity to be in photos I would in no other way be able to.

2.       No one is left out: While this is an addendum to the first point, it is still valid. How many times at Christmas, a social event, etc have wanted a picture of the entire group but are not in a place where someone is available to take your photo? I know I have experienced this and what ends up happening is one person volunteers to take the photo, being left out of the picture and after many years pass, tends to be left out from the memory as well.  Face it, without visual representation we forget things easily and quickly. Now while I am not an advocate for a selfie stick, here is my rebuttle against it: does it really matter if a picture is taken with a tripod or with a stick?

3.       Close proximity: When taking a selfie, you are typically taking a close up as you can only extend your camera the length of the reach of your arm.  Because of this when taking a picture with anyone else you are forced to huddle close to each other in order to fit in the frame.  Do I even need to argue why this is a good thing?  Especially in an age where we have become more and more disconnected with other people as anything anymore is more technological that it is social.  Even on social media, most things I find posted are recipies, memes and videos.  Even though it only takes a couple seconds to take a selfie, it is a couple seconds you are interacting closely with a human being you care enough about to take a picture with.

4.       How you view yourself: Now for me, this one is the most important point of all. While I feel this applies to everyone, obviously my life experiences has given me a perspective from a woman’s point of view.  Everywhere you turn women are becoming more sexualized that ever before.  Commercials for underwear show as much as soft porn used to.  As women, we are caught in a society run juxtaposition: you are a beautiful object that should be shown off and appreciated, yet also, are shamed for posting pictures of ourselves and quickly labeled vain when we show our face or bodies for anything other than sex. I know that is a very rough generalization, but the point I am trying to make is this: we are ALWAYS being judged.  Once again, I am sure this applies to male and female alike, but I can only speak from my experiences.  A woman posts a photo and she is labeled vain, seeking attention, or trying to get an interest’s attention.  However, that is WRONG, and while I am sure some women post selfies for one of those reasons I am willing to bet it isn’t the majority as it seems to be stated.  I post selfies of myself for ME and me alone.  Facebook is an amazing thing as are other social media sites, but I upload all photos to Facebook so that I have them safely saved to a place other that my phone or my computer.  I post selfies to facebook because I like the way I view myself, and come on, isn’t that something we all struggle with?  For years I have faught with low self esteem, especially when it came to my weight and my looks.  So when there is a day that even though I am not at my goal weight, haven’t had my hair profecionally done, etc and still feel beautiful, I celebrate that with myself.  I love myself and there is NOTHING wrong with that.  In fact, I believe most people don’t love themselves enough, so then why when we are trying to reclaim the love we need to have, would you label and trash us “selfie takers?”

Now do we need selfies of you in your gym bathroom all over Facebook? Who am I to judge? Maybe that is the motivation that person needs: to look at themselves to see what they accomplish; to then inspire them to do it again tomorrow. The selfie is a great way to find new ways of expressing ourselves and loving ourselves.  I guess I pose this question and welcome all comments: If you are a selfie hater, what is it that make you so against them?
 

9 comments:

  1. I don't think there's a problem with taking them. I just get annoyed with the constant posting of them. I use Instagram to follow people I am interested in and see things that interest me. I get very annoyed seeing different angles and makeups of some woman's face/body all the time so I can tell her how much I like her new eyeshadow or how sexy she looks or otherwise praise her looks. It has caused me to unfriend/unfollow people who I am otherwise interested in following, whether it be their lives or their children or both.

    I guess the bottom line is, they mean something to you (assuming you are a 'selfie poster') for the reasons you mentioned, but to everyone else, they come across as nothing more than fishing for compliments. And more so, it makes me sad because women are so much more than our outside appearance, and I'd rather compliment a woman on her killer personality, amazing writing, awesome parenting, or innate kindness. Who cares if her cleavage looks awesome in her purple top or her eyes look fantastic in emerald green eyeshadow?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you 100% women should be complimented for more than just their looks, but unfortunately, from my experience, this isn't very common unless already in a relationship with a person. Women should be seen for more than just their physical appearance or sexual appeal, yet society has taught many young and old women alike that sadly, that is all they are. It is sad as society, media, and even some religions exploit women as being over-sexualized creatures; this title is derogatory and seen as such, yet over time we learn to believe this falsehood to a certain extend if not completely. That I feel your comment proves me point to a certain extent when you said: they mean something to you...for the reasons you mentioned, but to everyone else, they come across as nothing more than fishing for compliments. Meaning that no matter the reasons I post them, this is how it is viewed. Now, as stated, I do NOT post things to fish for compliments or to receive gratification from anyone. I treat my blog and my Facebook as a diary. while very public, it allows friends and family to know 100% where I am at, who I am etc. Being an Army wife for a while, I literally have friends all over the world and want to share with them my transformations. However, I can be in error as I assume, and whenever you assume you can always be in error, that because I have anterior reasons for posting selfies, I assume other people do as well. My thought is this: while I do not condone vanity, what is the harm in a woman feeling empowered by the way she looks?
      Now I hope you do not find my response argumentative or attacking as I was not intending that at all and I can very much validate how annoying it is to see certain things constantly in your news feed as I have my own annoyances with certain things, I truly was only hoping to understand the distaste behind the selfie. Have I even been insulted or offended by posting a selfie? No. Once again, only trying to gain a better understanding, so let me see if I understand you correctly: it isn't the selfie per say that annoys you, rather the magnitude in which you see them and the "implied" desire for posting it? If I have misunderstood you, please respond and thank you so very much for your comment; I really appreciate it!

      Delete
    2. Yes, that's correct. I am annoyed by the frequency, and the fact that it seems to be fishing for compliments. Regardless of the motive the poster thinks they have for posting them, all they need do is look in the comments to discern the message they are sending - it will be a litany of "you look great!" in different words.

      I once posted a selfie of myself with my young baby, because she looked super cute in it. I was disgusted when people right away started commenting on my haircut, because I realized that's the message I was sending - that I wanted people to pay attention to me.

      To a large degree, all reality is just perception. A guy in high school once told me "Reality is not a dream, but it is only as real as the dreamer who dreams it". I thought he was weird at the time, but as I've grown older, it makes sense. Reality exists only in our perception. Your reality will always be different from mine, and mine from my coworker's, etc. Reality is not the same to any two people. Look at court cases where witness testimonies to the same crime differ completely.

      So regardless of "why" you post selfies, the reality in the eyes of most people who see it is that you want attention.

      To use a an extreme example. If I wear a sheer top because it is comfortable and it breathes well in the summer heat, and also because it is an eco-conscious brand and I want to support their message, does that change the fact that anyone who sees my visible breasts will think I'm sending a COMPLETELY different message? Does it matter what they think? Of course not. But when I make the decision to wear it, I need to be aware of the message I am sending.

      Delete
  2. So your saying based on what other people perceive we should limit and censor ourselves? Because women are viewed in a sexual way, we should perpetuate the stereotype simply because people think that way anyway? I disagree. Be who you are and don't apologize for it as long as you ate not hurting or offending anyone. But as you said everyone has a different reality and I doubt there is anything I can say to change your mind, but I do have to point out and ask: you stated before that you have gone as far as to unfriend people due to selfie posts; that seems to go beyond annoyance to disgust. So the question is this why unfriend/judge a person over a selfie? Even if they are fishing for compliments as you assume, why unfriend them when they are looking to have someone fill a need? What is it about the selfie that is so abhorrent to you that causes someone to be that turned off by it? for me annoying means irritating; something I can deal with though I don't always want to. Do we just have different definitions of the words or do they disgust you?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm too busy for my feed to be clogged with someone else's ego, to be honest. I barely have time to check my Instagram feed before bed, if anyone I follow is posting too much stuff I don't care about, I unfollow them. It's not just selfies, although those are my pet peeve. I don't need to feed people's who and I resent the fishing. When I offer compliments they are unsolicited and genuine. But I also follow people who post too much other stuff that clogs my feed and isn't relevant to me:
    - selling products from home businesses
    - intactivist nuts with their constant penis talk
    - Posts wanting compliments on makeup or hair they did (stylists)
    - excessive preachy stuff. Daily bible quotes and such. (That stuff is cool in moderation but some people go nuts)

    Stuff like that. If I spend more time trying to avoid your posts than enjoying your posts, I unfollow

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Feed people's ego not who. Autocorrect

      Delete
    2. Ok thank you for the clarification. Once again, just different circumstances. I only have friends on Facebook that ate actually my friends. So everyone is someone I want to keep in contact with which is why I didn't understand. Though I still find it judgmental that it is determined someone takes a selfie only to feed their ego. If you were disgusted as you say when your selfie was addressed in such a way surprises me that you see them that way yourself when you say that's not the reason you posted one of your own. Once again just trying to clarify to understand and take into account all angled

      Delete
    3. I'm certain I'm not the only person who sees them that way - you are obviously aware of how it looks to others, because you posted a long blog post to justify them.

      (on a lighter note, it is nice to see your blog getting more attention. Your followers miss your posts!)

      Delete